Seriously Craveable
Scratch-made pies and treats prepared in small batches from family recipes JUST FOR YOU!

Mayville, WI  |  Retail Hours

  • Wednesday 4 - 8 pm
  • Thursday 11 - 8 pm
  • Friday 11 - 8 pm
  • Saturday 11 - 8 pm
  • Sunday 1 - 5 pm
What We've Got
  • 4 Pie Varieties - changes weekly
  • 1 Cake Variety - changes weekly
  • Cookies, brownies & bars
  • Chocolate Shoppe Ice cream
  • Ice cream pies
  • Take and bake pies
How to Order Online
  1. Check out our full selection of pie varieties on our order page
  2. Use the order now button (at the top of the page) to easily request a pick-up day/time of your choice
  3. Special requests like sugar-free, large orders, or questions?  Email your order button (just below) to get just what you want, made right when you need it.

Find us:

4 S Main Street
Mayville, WI 53050

Minnesota Retailer Locations


“My brother loved his birthday cake.  Thanks for making his day special.”

“Your pies and cookies are amazing.  I love to have a stash of them in my freezer at the cabin.”


“My friend loved her rhubarb pie. Plain rhubarb pie is hard to find.  Thanks for customizing our order. Can I get another one?”



We're growing and want to share our journey with you.  For news about new products, locations, and promotions subscribe today.  Don't worry, your mailbox won't be full by tomorrow.