Seriously Craveable
Scratch-made pies and treats prepared in small batches from family recipes JUST FOR YOU!
Scratch-made pies and treats prepared in small batches from family recipes JUST FOR YOU!
Mayville, WI | Retail Hours
- Wednesday 4 - 8 pm
- Thursday 11 - 8 pm
- Friday 11 - 8 pm
- Saturday 11 - 8 pm
- Sunday 1 - 5 pm
What We've Got
- 4 Pie Varieties - changes weekly
- 1 Cake Variety - changes weekly
- Cookies, brownies & bars
- Chocolate Shoppe Ice cream
- Ice cream pies
- Take and bake pies
How to Order Online
- Check out our full selection of pie varieties on our order page
- Use the order now button (at the top of the page) to easily request a pick-up day/time of your choice
- Special requests like sugar-free, large orders, or questions? Email your order button (just below) to get just what you want, made right when you need it.
Find us:
Testimonials
“My brother loved his birthday cake. Thanks for making his day special.”
KD
KD
“Your pies and cookies are amazing. I love to have a stash of them in my freezer at the cabin.”
CJ
CJ
“My friend loved her rhubarb pie. Plain rhubarb pie is hard to find. Thanks for customizing our order. Can I get another one?”
DG
